What is the difference between a RingString picture and WireStyle?

Comparison of a RingString picture and a String Art picture from WireStyle

What is a RingString string art picture?

A Ring String picture is a round string art picture, as sold by many suppliers, in which the nails are arranged on the outside of a circle. The string is stretched between these nails to create the motif. Because the nails are only placed on the outside of the edge, very few nails are used overall and the resulting image effectively has a much lower resolution. The advantage, however, is that it is much easier to produce than a string art picture from WireStyle and is therefore also suitable for making by hand at home.

Difference between a RingString picture and a WireStyle string art picture

The main difference lies in the number of nails used and therefore the level of detail that can be achieved. While Ring String pictures typically use approx. 200 - 400 nails, a WireStyle string art picture consists of approx. 3000 - 12,000 nails, depending on the size. Because WireStyle does not just place the nails at the edge, the laid string can change direction at very short intervals and therefore follow contours better. This creates a much more photorealistic impression. 

Petros Vrellis, the inventor of the RingString images

In 2016, Petros Vrellis, an internationally renowned computer artist from Greece, published an algorithm with which he was able to calculate the optimal string connections of a Ring String string art picture. He describes this on his website. He sells his self-made round string art pictures through Saatchiart .

 

Petros Vrellis sells round string art pictures on Saatchiart, also known as RingString

 

 

Other suppliers of RingString

As Petros Vrellis has disclosed his algorithm, there are now numerous providers of Ring String string art pictures. With these providers, you can upload your own picture and receive a finished round string picture as a result. You can also buy DIY kits that contain all the necessary materials as well as an app that allows you to convert a photo into a nail list that you can then trace with the string. With a lot of patience, you can create a round string art picture.

If you want to produce several round RingString string art pictures, you can also buy ready-made machines that automatically rotate the round plate and pull the string around the next nail, producing the picture fully automatically after a short time.

Petros Vrellis' algorithm has now been taken up in several open source projects and published on Github .

Some of these projects also offer a free calculation option that runs directly in the browser without the need to install any software. This means that anyone can calculate their own RingString image from a photo as a template free of charge. One of the most convenient programs for this comes from Jérémie Piellard.

Based on Jérémie Piellard's Github project, another programmer also developed a free Android app called Thread Art (String Art) , which also offers this calculation.


Another popular free program is the String Art Generator by Halfmonty:

The String Art Generator program from Halfmonty

In addition to round RingString images, some of these programs also offer the option of calculating rectangular or oval images. Here too, the nails are all on the outer edge, resulting in a very similar, low-detail look to the round images.

The WireStyle machines compared to RingString machines

While production machines for Ring String can be bought ready-made and there are also numerous DIY projects, WireStyle's machines have been developed entirely in-house. The main reason for this is that with RingString the nails are only on the outside of the plate, so it is sufficient to turn the plate to reach all the nails. With a string art picture from WireStyle, all nails are placed at individually calculated positions. This means that the head of the thread-pulling robot and the nail robot must be moved in at least 2 axes in order to reach all positions. Although you can buy CNC routers, plotters and surface gantries that can move in two axes, these cannot drive nails and are not suitable for navigating between the nails at high speed due to their low acceleration.

André Gall from WireStyle calculates the nail positions and the course of the string path for a string art picture

The software for calculating the optimal nail positions and the path of the string was also programmed by WireStyle itself, as these calculations are much more complex and the algorithms programmed for Ring String are not sufficient for this.

 

Comparison of a ring string string art picture with a string art picture calculated by WireStyle

In comparison: (left) Ringstring string art picture with 288 nails and 4000 connecting lines, calculated with the String Art Generator on Github. (right) The same image with the self-programmed software from WireStyle calculated with 6598 nails and 53753 segments with a total of 912 m of string.

 

We have summarized more information about the production of WireStyle string art pictures here.

You can try out your own photos in the configurator, where you get a preview of how the picture will look later as a string art picture.

Reading next

A string art picture is made by multiple people by hand with a DIY set
A string for string art being held between fingers